Charismatic Leadership...

Is it a Blessing or a Curse?

Discover the advantages and disadvantages of being a charismatic leader, along with the leadership qualities that can round out this leadership style

A charismatic leader is a leader whose followers are attracted to his or her personality and charm.

People who use this leadership style excel at working a room.

They are masters at inspiring others to feel that they, (the leader), are critical to the 'cause' being successful. These magnetic leaders do this through actions such as:

  • Direct eye contact
  • Remembering personal details about the person they are speaking with e.g. use of name or asking after family/social matters
  • Giving their complete focus to the other person for the time they are with them
  • Reading their surroundings and being skilled at detecting the moods of the audience and
  • Adjusting his or her behaviors and speech to suit the situation at hand

Their approach when leading teams is to have their enthusiasm rub off on their team members by being extremely positive and energetic. Teams do, however, need more than just a charming leader to keep them sustainable over the long term.

Charismatic leadership like puppies, highly irresistible

Charismatic leaders are like puppies .... highly irresistible!

Advantages of Charismatic Leadership

  • 1
    Selling The Vision. These leaders are often exceptional at selling the vision and getting people to come along for the ride. They are geniuses at helping people to see possibilities and potentials ... to buy into something bigger than themselves. They are generally masters at weaving stories and anecdotes that enable people to buy into a big dream - e.g. JFK leading a nation to put the first man on the moon.
  • 2
    Inspiring. Their generally optimistic, and positive nature draws people to them like a moth to a flame. Often these leaders inspire people to be at their best, and the work environments they create can be very motivating to employees and colleagues alike.
  • 3
    Drive Results. A highly charismatic leader can have people willing to walk over hot coals for him or her. Because of this, they can achieve results and often get things done that other leadership styles may not. Think Hitler, Lee Iacocca, Steve Jobs, Richard Branson, Oprah Winfrey, Michelle Obama, Stacey Abrams, Brene Brown

Charismatic Leadership Pitfalls

  • 1
    Group Think. Because these leaders are so popular it can cause team members to stifle their own beliefs and values if they are in conflict with those of the leader. The danger in this is that you get 'group think' and/or people going along with the ride even when they sense that maybe the direction they are heading in is shaky.
  • 2
    Lack of Independence. Teams being lead by a charismatic leader can struggle to become more self-managing because the group's identity can become caught up in that of the leader and his or her ego. The team can often focus on the leader to help them succeed rather than building the systems and self-fortitude to think and act independently.
  • 3
    The leader's ego overtakes. These Leaders can sometimes get too caught up in their own ego and needs and this can have a devastating impact on the team. Think Donald Trump!
  • 4
    Company strength is under-acknowledged. The worst case scenario with having a charismatic leader in charge of an organization is when people start to believe the leader, somehow 'is' the company and that the company's success is tied to this person being at the helm.

Richard Branson of Virgin, and Southwest's Herb Kelleher, are both examples of leaders who are 'hero' worshiped by their team members.

The potential downside for these leaders is that people have put such faith in their leadership (and not the company as a whole) that they begin to believe that without him or her the company's infrastructure might break down.


As we have seen with Steve Job's passing in 2011 (and his firing from Apple in the mid-80s), organization's can survive the departure of even the most charismatic of leaders. Let's just hope, that Steve's legacy, (this time), is he has left behind an organization that thrives, not just survives, after he's gone.

Final Thoughts

Charismatic leadership is certainly a dynamic and empowering form of leadership and combined with other styles of leadership, it creates a powerful force that gives people the enthusiasm and self-management to achieve great results.

Related Articles


What are Your Thoughts?

Do you work with a charismatic leader? Or maybe you've watched, with fascination, the antics of a high profile leader? Use the comments box below, and let me know what you have found to be the best of, or worst of being caught up in the world of these types of men and women.

More Resources to Support Your 'Rockstar' Leadership Career

Become a Member

Access all the ebooks, checklists, templates and other resources in the gated area of the Make A Dent Club

Personal Development

Access 60+ free resources to help you shine. From emotional intelligence to mindset to understanding others

Improve Teams

Access 20+ articles on how to shift your team from performing to high-performing. These are proven techniques and tips

Influencing Others

From dealing with difficult people, to resolving conflict, to building stronger relationships, all the resources you need are here


Resources and articles to help you shift from being a good to a 'Rockstar' leader. Over 20 resources waiting to inspire you to new levels of performance

Culture & Change

Your team's culture is at the heart of your business performance. Designed to help you lead organizational culture change 

Templates & Checklists

Speed up your productivity and implementation with these checklists and templates


Visit the store to purchase the ebooks, e-courses that take you to another level


Quizzes and self-assessments to help you track your progress and where you need to focus